Introspection and Poetry for a Meaningful Bioethics

Abstract

This commentary examines James Dwyer’s exploration of bioethics as presented in “Frameworks and Practices in Bioethics”, tracing his transition from Rawls’ theory of justice to the reflective practice of haiku and ultimately to Dewey’s pragmatism. Through this journey, Dwyer introduces a creative approach that leverages introspective tools to enhance ethical awareness and address complex issues. Despite its innovative nature, he questions the practical outcomes of these methods, noting their limited tangible impact and challenges in generating actionable solutions. This commentary highlights the strengths of Dwyer’s approach, particularly its ability to foster openness and innovation in bioethical thinking, while also addressing its limitations, such as the difficulty in bridging the gap between theoretical abstraction and practical application. The analysis underscores the value of interdisciplinary and flexible methods in navigating contemporary bioethical challenges, advocating for a balance between introspection and pragmatic action. Ultimately, Dwyer’s work underscores the importance of reflective and creative practices in shaping the future of bioethics, even as it grapples with its own constraints.